Division Rock

Editorial Reviews
About the Artist
Working as a school psychologist in 1986, Richard Caudle saw the need for multi-sensory learning programs using the styles of music that kids love. He teamed with his younger brother Brad, an accomplished musician, to record their first program to teach multiplication facts. Richard and Brad continue to produce many more audio and video programs featuring "cool music that teaches" covering math, phonics, early learning, languages, science, social studies, and more.

Album Description
Fun rockin' songs help teach division facts through 9. Separate songs for each set of facts. By singing along with the facts (in mixed-up order), students develop quick and accurate recall. 30-minute audio CD and book help students learn in a format similar to shuffled "musical flash cards." Book includes puzzles and math mazes. Ages 9 & up.

Division Rock, Music, Rock 'n Learn
The Division Bell
Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
  • excellent
  • Comfortably Numb
  • There is nothing wrong with this album. It's all in your mind.
  • A good solo album from David Gilmour
  • Not One of the Floyd's Best Efforts
The Division Bell
Pink Floyd
Manufacturer: Sony
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
Progressive RockProgressive Rock | Progressive | Rock | Styles | Music
Psychedelic RockPsychedelic Rock | Classic Rock | Styles | Music
Album-Oriented Rock (AOR)Album-Oriented Rock (AOR) | Classic Rock | Styles | Music
SupergroupsSupergroups | Classic Rock | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Classic Rock | Styles | Music
Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
$8.99 and Under$8.99 and Under | Blowout Music | Stores | Music
PopPop | Styles | Blowout Music | Stores | Music
Classic RockClassic Rock | Styles | Blowout Music | Stores | Music
RockRock | Styles | Blowout Music | Stores | Music
All Blowout MusicAll Blowout Music | Blowout Music | Stores | Music
$8.99 and Under$8.99 and Under | Prices | Blowout Music | Stores | Music
More Titles at Least 25% OffMore Titles at Least 25% Off | Blowout Music | Stores | Music
Similar Items:
  1. A Momentary Lapse of Reason
  2. Wish You Were Here
  3. Animals
  4. The Wall (Deluxe Packaging Digitally Remastered)
  5. Meddle

ASIN: B000002A3T
Release Date: 1994-04-05

Tracks:

  1. Cluster One
  2. What Do You Want From Me
  3. Poles Apart
  4. Marooned
  5. A Great Day For Freedom
  6. Wearing The Inside Out
  7. Take It Back
  8. Coming Back To Life
  9. Keep Talking
  10. Lost For Words
  11. High Hopes

Amazon.com

As Roger Waters's solo career set into a sunset of suspiciously self-serving Wall revivals and compelling if modest-selling solo efforts, his former band became one of the few outfits in the soft live market of the 1990s to burnish its stadium-filling appeal. But their recorded output wasn't quite so rosy. As all post-Dark Side of the Moon albums must have a Big Important Theme, The Division Bell is vaguely about levels of separation (did you say, duh!?), with more than one not-so-opaque lyrical jab at the estranged Waters. But there's a sense that the band may have put more thought into its trademark audio gimmickry (well represented here by the actual sound of the earth's crust cracking--you don't get that on Rage Against the Machine albums!--and a "spoken" intro by Dr. Stephen Hawking, or rather his voice synthesizer) than it did into its songs this time around. The opening "Cluster One" has a hypnotic minimalist lure that dissolves all too quickly into the bluesy waffle of "What Do You Want From Me," while Floyd Mach III leader Dave Gilmour's usually lyrical guitar work is uninspired throughout, a definite Floydian slip. Still, the band maddeningly manages a few moments of the old grandeur here and there. The Division Bell is not a great Pink Floyd album, but an all-too-fallible simulation. --Jerry McCulley

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars excellent.......2007-06-13

Great companion CD to the Pulse DVD. Must have.

2 out of 5 stars Comfortably Numb.......2007-05-17


Purists will argue that Pink Floyd without Roger Waters, is a bit like Beatles without John Lennon. Some unkind souls might even go further to say that it's a bit like Beatles without John or Paul. Without Roger, gone is the confrontation, the poetry, seismic visions of a world teetering on the brink of moral collapse. Gone is the intellectual bite, the naked anguish, the bile, the howling and the ultimate catharsis of the final track. What's left is good intentions, sleek musicianship, a hip brand, and a reassuringly expensive, car-stereo-friendly sound.

That's not to say that the Division Bell is a bad record, per se, some of it captures the old magic. The Gilmour, Wright & Mason partnership still know a good tune when they hear one, and David Gilmour can still work the magic with his guitar. But the thing is, without Waters' artistic vision and wit to provide a thematic backbone, the resultant music is comes across as high-quality sheen and veneer. To me this sounds more like a David Gilmour solo album than a Pink Floyd work. And I say that as a long-standing fan of the group.

This may sound uncompromising, and this isn't a bad album - but somewhere you have to draw the line between what is really good and what is merely passable; what qualifies as art and what is marketed as product. Fortunately, the general public seems to have given Pink Floyd the benefit of the doubt; the sympathy vote came into play after nasty old Roger Waters left the ship, taking his rough edges and intellectual pretensions with him, leaving nice David Gilmour and the unfairly sidelined Wright and caught-in-the-crossfire Nick Mason to continue flying the Floyd flag. This goodwill, coupled with the eternal hipness of the Pink Floyd brand, have combined to give Floyd a new lease of life and cash-register-eyes album sales.

Musically, the band retreads old ground on much of the album. On Cluster, it's back to Wish You Were Here and the group tries to breath new life into the atmospheric intro formula of Shine On You...part 1. On 'What Do You Want From Me?' we revisit Dark Side of the Moon territory, completely with gospel backing vocals, trademark DG solo à la Time. Here again, it all gels together quite nicely, with David Gilmour handling guitar and vocal duties with aplomb. But it's bathed in so much reverb that the groups sounds like it's playing down the far end of the Grand Canyon.

On Take it Back, Pink Floyd come on like a cross between U2 and Dire Straits, while on Great Day for Freedom, tired imagery and a pedestrian melody remind us once again how important Mr. Waters was the formula.
High Hopes probably constitutes the quality core of this record, an impressive dirge that captures the spirit of Comfortably Numb, though even this song is let down by a tediously repetitive middle-8, sure sign of lack of artistic urgency.
To sum up, this record sounds big and expensive and sold in bucketloads, but for me, it lacks the substance and inventiveness to satisfy the 'serious' Pink Floyd fan.

5 out of 5 stars There is nothing wrong with this album. It's all in your mind........2007-04-23

Pink Floyd has always been great "head music". A lot of time had passed by since their high water mark, 1973's Dark Side of the Moon and this album (1994). If it had been released 20 years earlier in 1974, it would have been hailed a masterpiece. I've listened to this album very closely and still found them to be the best purveyors of head music. I can't understand the cynical and disrespectful comments about this album, mostly from folks who weren't even alive when Dark Side came out. Bottom line: If you like Pink Floyd's weird sounds, and surreal soundscapes, you'll love this album. If you're hopping on the latest bandwagon, keep the negativity to yourself and stick to American Idol. Real Pink Floyd fans know "The Division Bell" is really a very good album even without Roger Waters.

3 out of 5 stars A good solo album from David Gilmour.......2007-03-05

I have to agree with many reviewers this time. We are light year away from a true Pink Floyd album, the spirit is not here and the music is quite near to pop sometimes. We have some good tracks hidden in the cd, the best one is "High Hopes", the other interesting cuts are intrumental, "Cluster One" and "Marooned" The other track are just OK but far from memorable composition. "Wearing the inside out" is a real joke.

3 out of 5 stars Not One of the Floyd's Best Efforts.......2007-03-01

This CD brings back memories from my junior high days and is the first Pink Floyd CD that I ever listened to. I do like the album overall, but in relation to their complete body of work this has to rank among their bottom. The only other albums that may be worse are Ummagumma or A Saucerful of Secrets.

But this does contain some great songs. Such as: High Hopes, Wearing the Inside Out, Keep Talking, Coming Back to Life, and Poles Apart. The songwriting and guitar playing could have been better though. Hopefully this isnt their last recording and they will reunite and make one last great album.
Nouvelle Vague
Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
  • Lounge with spunk
  • In Love With This Album!
  • Brilliantly different...
  • Relaxing AND Catchy!
  • Mixed bag gives bossa nova swing to olde inde faves
Nouvelle Vague
Nouvelle Vague
Manufacturer: Luaka Bop
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Dance & DJ | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Dance Pop | Dance & DJ | Styles | Music
FranceFrance | Continental Europe | Europe | International | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Euro Pop | Pop | Styles | Music
French PopFrench Pop | Euro Pop | Pop | Styles | Music
Similar Items:
  1. Bande a Part
  2. Brazilian Girls
  3. Talk to La Bomb
  4. Let It Die
  5. Latenighttales: Nouvelle Vague

ASIN: B0007YMVOW
Release Date: 2005-05-03

Tracks:

  1. Love Will Tear Us Apart
  2. Just Cant Get Enough
  3. In A Manner Of Speaking
  4. Guns Of Brixton
  5. This Is Not A Love Song
  6. Too Drunk To ****
  7. Marian
  8. Making Plans For Nigel
  9. A Forest
  10. I Melt With You
  11. Teenage Kicks
  12. Psyche
  13. Friday Night Saturday Morning
  14. Sorry For Laughing

Amazon.com

Recycling the 1980s sound has been in vogue lately, so it's no surprise that the producing team known as Nouvelle Vague would find yet another way to mine the nostalgia for the early `80s, post-punk era. They're doing it bossa nova style.

The disc opens with a rendition of Joy Division's "Love Will Tear Us Apart." It's a charming start, and with a breathy chanteuse on vocals, it's exactly the kind of sound that has some music critics proclaiming (admittedly with a touch of sarcasm) that Nouvelle Vague is the ironic dinner music for the new millennium. Unfortunately, this CD is somewhat less winning as it wears on. "Guns of Brixton" is annoying when done in a loungey mood, and sitting through "Too Drunk to F**k" in the wrong company could certainly ruin the amuse bouche. Nevertheless, the entertaining tracks do outweigh tiresome ones on this release. If this concept sounds like an interesting idea to you, you're bound to get a smile from the execution. --Leah Weathersby

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars Lounge with spunk.......2007-07-08

Or is it punk? Anyway I've got a weak spot for lounge music and this may best, edgiest lounge you'll ever hear. Frankly, I'm not all that familiar with most of the originals so I have no idea how much they've been maimed here. All I know is that the vocals are inspired and impossible to ignore.

5 out of 5 stars In Love With This Album!.......2007-06-07

I absolutely LOVE this album! I listen to many different genres of music but I have to say that this album is one of my ultimate favorite cd's! I don't get tired of listening to it! I'm so glad I was introduced to Nouvelle Vague and I have shared this cd with many friend of mine...I then recently purchased their second album Bande A Part, but I was disappointed however, it's not nearly as good as their first...I love 80's music, Bossa Nova, AND Nu Wave, definetly recommend this cd!

4 out of 5 stars Brilliantly different..........2007-04-15

First time through this distinctly "left field" album is likely to leave you a bit confused... laid back interpretations of classic 80's rock tracks served up as nonchalant, bossa-nova driven Anglo-French lounge music. Ridiculous? Well, fortunately not, because in here are some absolute gems - so good that once you've locked into what's going on you'll find them completely irresistible. Which ones depends on where you were at the time but, for me, "Teenage Kicks", "Love Will Tear Us Apart", "We're Only Making Plans for Nigel" & "Just Can't Get Enough" are so beautifully structured and darkly exciting that they're worth the price of the album on its own. But, as you'll see from the other reviews, there's a lot more on offer. Sure, some tracks miss it... but most don't and, insidious and clever, they add up to a brilliant, very different and probably unrepeatable "one off".

5 out of 5 stars Relaxing AND Catchy!.......2007-04-10

Well .... this album combines two of the better qualities I like in a CD. Nouvelle Vague is relaxing -- and extremely catchy! 'Love Will Tear Us Apart' sets the tone from the very beginning ... the comfortable bossa nova rhythm leads to a chorus I found myself whistling along with ... while Nouvellle Vague's catchy take on 'Just Can't Get Enough' had me humming along. I mentioned in another review that I'm not too familiar with the 70s/80s originals ... and because of that I find that this album of covers is a stand-alone, especially for those that are fans of rhythmic bossa nova, samba, and jazz. For me, every song on this album is strong ... As a picky and eccentric listener, this is one of the few times I can play through an entire album and never have to skip a track. It doesn't mean that I don't have favorites on this album -- 'Marian' was the reason I decided to buy the CD. I bought this CD with Bande a Part, because there were several songs on that CD that I felt compliment this one ... but this CD, Nouvelle Vague, is the stronger of two excellent CDs.

4 out of 5 stars Mixed bag gives bossa nova swing to olde inde faves.......2007-01-23

This outing from the cover band Novelle Vague satisfies immensely in many ways, and just plain misses in others. If you are an old timmer who grew up on the originals (like me) then you may find this newly vamped bossa nova approach to 80s post-punk staples a fun filled romp down nostalgia lane. It isn't for everyone, though, and a word of caution to those of you who are missing out by not having heard the originals (all brilliant in their own right) first. The often covered Joy Division classic, "Love Will Tear Us Apart," gives us a warmer rendition than the bleak original, but not better, just different. Of stellar mention is their fun, catchy cover of the DK's hc classic "Too Drunk to..." and the Clash's London-calling era ska-soaked "Guns of Brixton." I will also add that their cover of the insufferably boring "This is not a Love Song" (of disco-era post-Pistols Johnny Rotten PIL fame) gets a great face lift...upwards: Simply awesome!! On the other hand, Nouvelle Vague miss almost entirely on the gothic realm, as best evidenced by their butchering of Andrew Eldritch's "Marian" (off the Sisters of Mercy's first LP, "First and Last and Always") and with their mediocre quickening of The Cure's "A Forest" (which seems to be popular in covering, especially with the techno / rave crowd). Overall this is a good buy, but it does have a couple renditions that deserve a quick skip with a toggle of the fast forward button. A better NV effort is showcased in their "Bande A Part" LP, where they do a fantastic cover of the power-punk-pop classic "Ever Fallen in Love," a former Buzzcocks masterpiece. 4 stars for effort and originality.
Substance
Average customer rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
  • new taste
  • Apples to Oranges
  • Good
  • Great CD to own
  • Leaves me speechless
Substance
Joy Division
Manufacturer: Qwest / Wea
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
Hardcore & PunkHardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music | Vinyl Records | American Punk | British Punk | Emo | Garage Punk | Hardcore | Post Hardcore | Proto Punk | Punk | Punk Revival | Punk-Pop | Riot Grrl | Ska Punk | Straight Edge
New WaveNew Wave | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
Post-PunkPost-Punk | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
InnovatorsInnovators | Warner Brothers Records | Stores | Music
Similar Items:
  1. Unknown Pleasures
  2. Closer
  3. Substance
  4. Power, Corruption & Lies
  5. The Best of New Order

ASIN: B000002LEU
Release Date: 1990-10-25

Tracks:

  1. Warsaw
  2. Leaders Of Men
  3. Digital
  4. Autosuggestion
  5. Transmission
  6. She's Lost Control
  7. Incubation
  8. Dead Souls
  9. Atmosphere
  10. Love Will Tear Us Apart
  11. No Love Lost
  12. Failures
  13. Glass
  14. From Safety To Where
  15. Novelty
  16. Komakino
  17. These Days

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars new taste.......2007-07-06

I purchased this album on a lark because an ex-boyfriend has loved them and so I wanted to check them out. I absolutely love this record! My favorite songs are Digital and She's Lost Control. I listen to this when I'm cleaning my apt. because it gets me energized.

3 out of 5 stars Apples to Oranges.......2007-05-13

We really can't compare Joy Division to bands like New Order... they are very different. New Order is mostly synthesized, whereas this is very raw guitar, plus a lot darker. They are known as being influencial to the punk rock industry, paving the way for bands like The Cure.

This isn't my favorite album or band by far, but at the very least should be appreciated.

I wish the sound quality wasn't so poor, though. Makes the album a little difficult to jam to.


1 out of 5 stars Good.......2006-12-25

Hey, I suppose that Joy Division is so highly praised by critics because their singer has killed him self and was giving signs that he would do it in his music. Honestly speaking, bands like them are not that bad, but Punk came to tell that one should not take rock so seriously ( which I don't agree but then that was Punk's moto ) while critics tend to preach this, they take bands like Joy Division so seriously that we may find that they are as important as The Beatles for our pop culture, which they were not definitely. So, it is strange to see so many guys and girls that have never studied music to adore albums just because they are full of good poetry ( can't disagree )
but are rather simplistic musically speaking. I would rather enjoy the Sex Pistols or Ramones, they are the kind of punk that grabs me.

5 out of 5 stars Great CD to own.......2006-12-13

On this CD, Joy Division and Martin Hannett offer a mixture of rock-punk because it's more rock than punk with tracks like "Failures", "No Love Lost", "Leaders of men" and "Warsaw". It also includes more experimental digital sounds with "Transmission" and "Digital". Also, the song they're most known for, "Love will tear us apart". The sounds and lyrical content are very modern although dark, this record is timeless! It's for music lovers!

5 out of 5 stars Leaves me speechless.......2006-07-07

This is it. You've found it. Look no further. Because, my friends, music does not get any better than this. Every song, every lyric reaches down and soothes my darkest depths. I find myself at a loss of words because nothing can describe something so beautiful but the music itself. Give this cd patience. It's challenging but it grows, and it grows, and it grows. New Order does not even compare to the genious of Ian Curtis. Whatever possessed him to trancend all that seems humanly possible?
Unknown Pleasures
Average customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars
  • Shades of Grey
  • Track Listing Peculiar
  • correct track listing
  • innovative pioneers
  • Depressive Pleasures
Unknown Pleasures
Joy Division
Manufacturer: Qwest / Wea
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
Hardcore & PunkHardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music | Vinyl Records | American Punk | British Punk | Emo | Garage Punk | Hardcore | Post Hardcore | Proto Punk | Punk | Punk Revival | Punk-Pop | Riot Grrl | Ska Punk | Straight Edge
New WaveNew Wave | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
Post-PunkPost-Punk | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
Similar Items:
  1. Closer
  2. Substance
  3. Still
  4. Power, Corruption & Lies
  5. Entertainment

ASIN: B000002LGL
Release Date: 1990-10-25

Tracks:

  1. Disorder
  2. Day Of the Lords
  3. Candidate
  4. Insight
  5. New Dawn Fades
  6. She's Lost Control
  7. Shadowplay
  8. Wilderness
  9. Interzone
  10. I Remember Nothing

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars Shades of Grey.......2006-11-13

This is an album that displays emtion in each of its song. Unlike many of todays artist who pose for certain look or stlye, Joy Division were about channeling their emotions through their music. Unknown Pleasures, a landmark album the world was not ready for its time of release and yet still an album that sounds fresh and not dated. From the opening track Disorder to the track I Rememeber Nothing, the album is a sonic venture unlike the world has seen. She's Lost Control alone a track that makes you feel like you are on the edge of losing control. Seeing footage of Ian Curtis perform SLC is simply shocking. As the beat of the Stephen Morris drums fuel the gyrations of what seems to be an Ian Curtis in a state of epilepsy, one can wonder how Ian didnt lose control there and then. Whereas the power of Shadowplay can be summoned up in one lyric "In the Shadowplay acting out your own death.." Unknown Pleasures offers us a view into Joy Divisions world. A dystopia in shades of grey.

5 out of 5 stars Track Listing Peculiar.......2006-11-01

Amazon sort out your track listing for this album you dense sick motherfu$$ers..........and remember to clean your teeth afterwards.

This album desrves much much better than to be tagged with incorrect information being unique in its genre or rather inventing its own genre unlike yourselves.........I tell ya wat if you lot were a river i'd dam you.

5 out of 5 stars correct track listing.......2006-10-14

Amazon tsk tsk tsk... you got the product description and track listing wrong! Get with it guys!
REAL track listing:

1.Disorder - 3:32
2.Day of the Lords - 4:50
3.Candidate - 3:05
4.Insight - 4:29
5.New Dawn Fades - 4:48
6.She's Lost Control - 3:57
7.Shadowplay - 3:56
8.Wilderness - 2:38
9.Interzone - 2:16
10.I Remember Nothing - 5:52

5 out of 5 stars innovative pioneers.......2006-10-09

highly influental and can never be compared to. so many artists try to cover their songs and all seem to fail miserably to grasp the sound, especially all the electronic artists. give it up!! get off your computer and play some instruments if you want to cover a band like joy division!

am i the only one that notices that amazon has the track list wrong? or did the band change the titles at one point?

4 out of 5 stars Depressive Pleasures .......2006-10-01

"Joy Division's " first album-- Unknown Pleasures (1979))--launches a scathing sucker punch to humanity that will turn your Peter Pan "happy thoughts" aflame. Through daunting singer/songwriter Ian Curtis--an artiste that uses his pessimistic lyrics as a comment on societal mores to promote subversion in the listener and make them question the bleaker aspects of everyday existence-- this unit achieves pathos in a number of ways; including Curtis' suicide shortly after recording the single, Love will Tear us Apart, shortly before the release of their second album, "Closer." This second-dimension to the refrain make this group from Manchester, England much more than the typical mainstream, jivey, and greedy bands that seem like they are only trying to become the next poster boys. Instead, it is an intriguing, as well as a heartbreaking listen to a man's final testament to the world and god that he feels betrayed by.

Their message is made apparent by Curtis' voice, lurching with a flat monotone, peeling the listeners' emotion away like a vagrant soul found in the pages of an Edgar Allen Poe story. Moreover, this relic of mirth is at the heart of the lyrical themes that range from betrayal, death, depression, religion, and crumbling sanity. This downbeat sensibility has the somberness of the broken-hearted youth in a Shakespearean tragedy, and the damnable suffering of a villain's final breath in the climax of a Jacobean revenge story. The "all is not well in wonderland" angst is apparent on Pleasure's opener, the emotionally withdrawn song, Disorder. Containing the daring first lyric, " I am waiting for the guide to come and take me by the hand," the refrain shows a loss of touch with reality, leading to a lust for death. It is this blur between the earthbound and the empyreal that makes "Joy Division" a landmark band that would set up the groundwork for other genres, such as Goth.

Bassist Peter Hook, drummer Stephen Morris, and guitarist Bernard Albrecht perform the sonic atmospherics. This British triple-threat adds to this emotional masterpiece of dark delicacies constructed from a vortex of fractured passions and disbanded ecstasies. Working as a collective whole, the members brandish a high concepted, yet refined minimalism in their sound that fluctuates from dizzyingly kinetic, to a subdued, unsettled tone; and it is in the passionate musical arrangements that a cough of life emerges. "Joy Division's" classical merit is an absolute, they are a fever-pitch of decadence, and a masterful band that transmitted their social concerns and lack of faith in the system into their music. Speaking on the unjust tragedy of Curtis' suicide, the audience must understand that true art is an emotional outlet for someone's own frustrations in the world, and no matter how blurred with reality it may be, art is always a form of self-expression, and communication. Thus by turning our back on the artists' views, because of their personal problems, we in turn dehumanize that person.

Moreover, despite their gloom-drenched aura, "soul" and "diversity" is at the hull of the band. The music itself speaks; frankly, re-animating the emotional somberness only for the album to stop spinning in the player, but not in the listeners' mind. Unknown Pleasures is not just a masterpiece of music, but rather an experience that brought artistry into the post-punk sound, and made it an emotional tool to break your heart, to then enclose the fragments in darkness. R.I.P. Ian Curtis


**** 1/2 (Out of 5)

Note- Only negative-- The overlong last song, "I remember nothing."


Closer
Average customer rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
  • 4.5/AS GOOD AS 'POST-PUNK' GETS
  • Top Ten Albums of All Time
  • Resignation achieved
  • Dark Stuff
  • Closure to a legacy
Closer
Joy Division
Manufacturer: Qwest / Wea
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
Hardcore & PunkHardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music | Vinyl Records | American Punk | British Punk | Emo | Garage Punk | Hardcore | Post Hardcore | Proto Punk | Punk | Punk Revival | Punk-Pop | Riot Grrl | Ska Punk | Straight Edge
Post-PunkPost-Punk | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
InnovatorsInnovators | Warner Brothers Records | Stores | Music
Similar Items:
  1. Unknown Pleasures
  2. Substance
  3. Still
  4. Power, Corruption & Lies
  5. Low-Life

ASIN: B000002LGN
Release Date: 1990-10-25

Tracks:

  1. Atrocity exhibition
  2. Isolation
  3. Passover
  4. Colony
  5. A Means To An End
  6. Heart & Soul
  7. Twenty Four Hours
  8. The Eternal
  9. Decades

Amazon.com

In retrospect, the second and final album by this Manchester postpunk band seems to point straight at singer Ian Curtis's suicide, which happened a few months before it was released. The band's reverberating mesh of minor-key lines and Curtis's tremorous bass voice are doomy enough on their own, and attention to the words reveals references to blacker-than-black stories by J.G. Ballard and Joseph Conrad; the void and its terrors were splitting Curtis apart from the inside. "I put my trust in you," he sings, and his voice leaves no doubt that that trust has been betrayed. But the music, grim and powerful as it is, points to the direction the surviving members took as New Order, incorporating the mechanical gravity of club rhythms. --Douglas Wolk

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars 4.5/AS GOOD AS 'POST-PUNK' GETS.......2007-06-30

Someone on Amazon said if 'you' don't like this Cd, 'you're' not human. I think that's an atrocious accusation, 'cause this CD is really difficult to get into. The production style is to sound what motor oil is to visual beauty...in other words, the sound is ugly. And the melodies don't make up for it. I figure that's the idea, so, b/c of that one person's ambitious statement about my/'your' lack of humanity, I decided to give this 1 or 2 more listens, just to see what on earth she (or maybe it was a he...) was talking about. Little by little I got more accepting of it. Eventually, I found a small bit of delight in the minimalistic production style and instrumentation, and that small delight grew and one day (today actually...) I found myself jumping for joy when I found this CD LOCALLY(!), for a reasonable price ($12.99+tax). I bought this at Barnes & Noble, which is not my first choice for buying CDS, but I think I might shop there more often, since, as I had known all along, their selection is vastly superior to these other junk CD shops in my home town (Cape Girardeau, MO; about two hours south of St. Louis). My finding of this CD confirms that. Anyhoo, this CD is mainly a mood piece, so it's definitely not a 'must have' for all music lovers and isn't even a must-listen most of the time, unless you're always/'most'ways in a gloomy depressed mood & can tolerate listening to the SAME THING DAY IN AND DAY OUT, but I guess there are quite a few people that are able to do that without boredom for a lot longer than I am. This CD is a small gem in the indie music world (and I mean 'indie' as in non-mainstream, not 'indie' as in owned-by-an-indie-label; sad I have to sepcify that, since the term 'alternative' used to mean exactly what 'indie' means today...). For $12.99 (or less if you live in a city that isn't full of small minded people who don't even have the will to listen to a well rounded selection of music even in the POP arena...), I'd say it was a worthy purchase.

I must say that I DO NOT like the majority of this type of music. I absolutely HATE The Psychedelic Furs' self titled album and the dozen or half dozen or so similiar albums I've heard. This is an exception, although I do plan to purchase UNKNOWN PLEASURES (also by Joy Division) sometime in the next month or two.

5 out of 5 stars Top Ten Albums of All Time.......2007-03-22

"Unknown Pleasures" always get the attention, but Closer is the album that should get it. A masterpiece- haunting, beautiful, desolate.

Frank Mehringer

5 out of 5 stars Resignation achieved.......2007-03-08

I read descriptions like austere, minimalist, dark, and brooding. All are appropos, but I like the word ausdarkminimbrood. Do you think Ian Curtis liked being depressed? I appreciate Ian Curtis's honesty; that is refreshing, but I wish he would have found the light and mixed that with his ample talent. Ian Curtis, although some would disagree, we hardly knew ye. Poor lad.

5 out of 5 stars Dark Stuff.......2007-01-23

Many fans are more partial to the punkier sound on 'Unknown Pleasures,' but I've always been partial to this one. It's difficult to get though because it is so relentless and dark. But it also represents a huge leap forward in Joy Division's songwriting and contains the best of Martin Hannett's atmospheric production. Lyrically, Ian Curtis builds a impressionist portrait of dystopia that may very be existence itself. The band build and sustain an tension on this album that occurs nowhere else in their works, or on any other album ever. Sure, their singles are brilliant, but this a complete work and is the best Joy Division's album the were able to make.

5 out of 5 stars Closure to a legacy.......2007-01-11


"Unknown Pleasures" was Joy Division using a slight punky aggression to convey their emotion of loneliness. That album was angry, pissed even, but on "Closer," this aggression is boiled down to vapidness, a reclusion of emotion, that almost seems like it is crying for help. Truth be told, this is to many singer/songwriter Ian Curtis' suicide note, with songs called: "A Means to an End," "The Eternal," and "Heart and Soul," making that conclusion seem not too far off from the truth. In a way, hearing this, is like a horrifying gunshot when surrounded in absolute darkness, or is as hopeless as a tear in the rain, and what more, it's a fascinating look at a man's battle cry to those who betrayed him, and no matter how morbid it seems, Curtis' heart and soul went into it, and created not just a good album, a great album, or even just a masterpiece, but an emotional ride into the depths of a soul, that is isolated, and ticked off.

"Closer" feels distant and off kilter, there is nothing about this album that is "mainstream." It lacks hooks, melody, and has a sense of restraint. Started with the song, Atrocity Exhibition, with Stephen Morris simple, tap-tap-tap, battle drum, that would go on in the rest of the album, amiss the subtle instrumentals. Aside from the slightly adrenaline-charged seventh song, Twenty-Four Hours, the music is part of an almost psychological deprivation experiment, creating glumness in the listener's heart. On Exhibition, the song makes social comments on survival of the fittest: "In arenas we kill for a prize," sings the somber piece, and earlier this track speaks of society's want to be entertained through others peoples' misfortunes, a sad sentiment indeed.

Before Ian Curtis killed himself, he suffered from epilepsy (something that Curtis sang about in, She's Lost Control, off of "Unknown Pleasures," even before having it himself.) Many also believed that Ian hanged himself due to a broken heart; and this sense of love lost bleeds through "Closer." Every song has a lingering sensation of paradise taken away: in the form of deflated hopes, damaged dreams, and begotten aspirations. The music may often overlap the words, but Curtis' sentiment is clear: he is not taken his depression lightly, as each song is just devoid of compassion, but at the same time is passionate, and reanimated in the musical ingenuities of drummer Morris, guitarist Bernard Albrecht, and bassist Peter Hook.

What else can be said about an album as important and talked about as this one, that has not already been written before, while still doing the album justice; let's just say: hear this, and then get the rest of their catalogue, as it will change how you look at music-- forever. Also, remember this album is how the memory of Curtis will live on, through our very belief in its power, him, life, and the affect of love. As "Closer" is possibly the most heartbreaking album of human emotion ever made, and in that way, it is the best music ever recorded. Period.

***** (Out of 5)
Still
Average customer rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
  • Not for the faint of heart....
  • An unusual document
  • Half and Half
  • No mistaking - the REAL Joy Division
  • Still is two great Joy Division Albums in one
Still
Joy Division
Manufacturer: Qwest / Wea
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
Hardcore & PunkHardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music | Vinyl Records | American Punk | British Punk | Emo | Garage Punk | Hardcore | Post Hardcore | Proto Punk | Punk | Punk Revival | Punk-Pop | Riot Grrl | Ska Punk | Straight Edge
Post-PunkPost-Punk | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
Similar Items:
  1. Unknown Pleasures
  2. Closer
  3. Substance
  4. Warsaw
  5. Movement

ASIN: B000002LOB
Release Date: 1991-02-19

Tracks:

  1. Exercise One
  2. Ice Age
  3. The Sound Of Music
  4. Glass
  5. The Only Mistake
  6. Walked In Line
  7. The Kill
  8. Something Must Break
  9. Dead Souls
  10. Sister Ray
  11. Ceremony
  12. Shadow Play
  13. Means To An End
  14. Passover
  15. New Dawn Fades
  16. Transmission
  17. Disorder
  18. Isolation
  19. Decades
  20. Digital

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars Not for the faint of heart...........2006-07-10

Joy Division were never a technically proficient band. For this they are either notorious or revered, depending on the person. I myself am of the latter persuasion. With this being said, I find Still to be a very difficult listen. The album's inadequate production has been well documented in many of these reviews. The inadequacies further exacerbate the band's lack of technical skill.

I myself happen to love Joy Division MOST for their unique approach to their instruments and songs. But to the uninformed, this cd makes them sound like the worst band ever. Peter Hook's bass is nearly impossible to hear on the average stereo system. It lacks a fullness that drives the album recordings. Since Hook's melodies are such a crucial aspect of the band's songs, I feel this is the worst part of Still's sound. Also, Ian Curtis' vocals on Ceremony are silent until the very end of the song, destroying any excitement one might glean from hearing such a rare recording. For these reasons, the album as a whole is not an easy listen.

So why do I give it five stars? Because Joy Division have influenced me tremendously. Despite all of it's shortcomings, Still communicates the band's final performance. It stands as a historical document to the world, an empowering testament to critics and fans alike. The imperfections in the band's performance bring the realization that it's members were indeed mere mortals. It gives hope to those of us who one day may wish to create something as beautiful and compelling as those brief years of Joy Division's life.

4 out of 5 stars An unusual document.......2005-08-16

First off, the morbid truth: the live album that makes up the second half of this collection is the last thing the band ever recorded; two weeks later singer Ian Curtis hung himself. So, in that regard this is a rather unique (and grim) audio snapshot of a truly tortured soul.

But dark romanticism or cheap sensationalism aside, the live set is almost all top quality, and well worth the purchase price. If you already have the box set, you have all the studio stuff - although one or two of these studio tracks have some extra (over?)production by Martin Hannett.

As far as the studio out-takes go, Dead Souls (a b-side) is essential. It's one of J.D.'s best songs, and also one of their best-known songs thanks to Nine Inch Nails' cover of it on the "Crow" soundtrack (a decent version, too). "The Only Mistake" is very good; it features the only 6/8 time signature in any J.D. song, and thus has a fast waltz-type feel. "Sound of Music" is great, but I like the Peel Session version better. Ditto for "Exercise One." "Something Must Break" is solid; "The Kill" and "Walked in Line" were basically early "punk" type songs that don't really work well with Ian's somber baritone.

"Sister Ray" originally closed Side 2 of the double album. On the CD, it sounds out-of-place in the middle of the album. And if one song had to be left off the disc due to space constraints, this probably should have been it. (They could have put it on the box set.) HOWEVER - I happen to love this cover of the Velvet Underground song - compared to the original, this is downright radio friendly! Plus it has my favorite Bernard Sumner moment ever: at the end of the song, he begins strumming a very bizarre chord and slowly decends down the neck. It's gloriously discordant, ultimately resolving perfectly. Then you hear Ian mumble "You should hear our version of Louie Louie" - an amusing image in its own right and also a reference to "John the Postman," a regular attendee of Manchester shows who used to leap on the stage at the end of shows and lead the crowd in a singalong of the Kingsmen classic.

The live album (or, in CD-speak, the last ten songs) captures the last J.D. show at Birmingham University. Unfortunately, the show opener, "Ceremony," has a cut-off beginning, and the vocal mic wasn't working for the first verse. Still, it sounds pretty amazing. This version of "Isolation" is, for me, the definitive version of the song; almost everything sounds really good, with one glaring exception:
"Decades" is one of the worst-sounding performances I think I have ever heard. Sometimes I just break down laughing at how utterly wrong it sounds. The problem was that Bernard's synthesizer had some kind of internal problems that caused its pitch to slowly increase; by the last chorus he was playing in a totally different key from Peter; Ian always had enough trouble staying on pitch when the band was in tune, so you can imagine the chaos that resulted here. Heck, they should have left THIS track off the CD if there wasn't enough space.

"Digital" is perfect, until the very end; Peter messes up the ending. Kind of fitting that this crazy band went out on a bum note.

WHAT ABSOLUTELY STINKS ABOUT THIS AND THE BOX SET: Once upon a time, "Still" was a double album. And at the end of side 3, there was a "hidden" track, not listed anywhere on the cover or label: "24 Hours." Since I still have my vinyl copy, I can attest to the fact that it was a great version of that great song (even though some of the vocals got lost in the mix). The fact that they cut it out of this CD reissue is lame. The fact that they ALSO didn't include it on the box set, meaning that it is completely unavailable on CD, is inexcusable.

This CD is worth buying just for "Dead Souls" and "Isolation."

4 out of 5 stars Half and Half.......2005-06-15

Still is a decent album for what it is, half and half. Half of the album is comprised of remains, leftovers that didn't make it on an album. While these songs are outtakes, they are strong on their own. While some will argue against the flow of these songs, I personally never had a problem with it. They fit fine in my mind.

The other half of this Half and Half album is a live recording, Joy Division's last concert, about 2 weeks prior to Ian Curtis' suicide. This concert has it's moments, but it is the novelty of being the final live Joy Division recording that makes it interesting.

Finally, there is the Sister Ray. A Velvet Underground cover from another concert entirely, and appearently a closer or encore of a show. You either like this song or hate it. It seems out of place to me.

I find a few faults with Still.

First off, it is a shame that the opener of the final concert live material is so badly recorded. It cuts in after the song has kicked off and there were mic to soundboard issues which leave the first verse a quiet ambient echo from the audiance. Sadly the song they kicked off with was Ceremony, a great tune that hadn't been fully developed in the studio yet. There is a demo studio version of this song on Heart and Soul (from my understanding) but really it will be remembered as a New Order tune.
Secondly, on the vinyl there is an uncredited song within the live material, that being Twenty Four Hours. A great song which doesn't make it to the CD, because it wouldn't fit. Knowing that the concert is incomplete bothers me, as does not having one of my favorite songs from the tape I had of my friend's vinyl copy circa 1987.
Next up, Sister Ray. Sister Ray, for what it is worth, is completely out of place. They could have cut Sister Ray out and put in Twenty Four Hours, but no, they didn't do that. Sister Ray serves to break up the flow of the album (The live stuff starts with Sister Ray, obviously a concert closer)and it is pretty bad in my opinion. Some people love it, I find it hard to listen to. Half of the time it gets skipped when I listen to the CD.

Finally, there are just some spots in the concert that Curtis wasn't up to form. There is a spot where he must have left his mic behind and wandered off, still singing.

Even with these shortcomings, Still is still a good album. Ceremony is a great song regardless of the technical difficulty, most of the live stuff is heartfelt and top form, and the studio remainders are fairly decent songs in there own right. Because of this I recommend buying this CD.

5 out of 5 stars No mistaking - the REAL Joy Division.......2005-06-08

Studio album or not, this disk seems to give the best picture of what Joy Division really was . The first track creates an incredibly haunting atmosphere, while tracks like 'Ice Age' & 'Walked In Line' capture the aggressive punk sound they started with. The best is that long, slow & obsessively gloomy songs that appear on Unknown Pleasures & Closer are mostly absent here. Instead, what you get is more of the edgy, psychologically complex material that marked them as a band ahead of their time - with less wasteful wallowing. It seems strange that this disk is often overlooked, considering that some of Joy Division's most interesting work - including the amazing 'Something Must Break' are represented here. It stands on it's own as a great disk that holds up well under the test of time.

5 out of 5 stars Still is two great Joy Division Albums in one.......2005-01-28

On many levels I would say that "Still" is the best Joy Division Album available. I know you purists out there will derride me for this but eventhough it is a hack job of unreleased tracks and a less than perfectly recorded concert it provides a deeper glimpse into the band their styles and and their work at large than any other JD album. I highly recommend this album as the FIRST JD album a person should choose. I want to break my commentary into two parts each part of the album, the unreleased tracks and the live concert recording, are essentially different albums on one CD.

The unreleased tracks which make up of the first half of the album are all for the most part great songs and while I have hear the argument that they don't flow together well, I have never been able to notice that. In fact I would argue the exact opposite. In comparison to Substance (the other Hack-job album) and Unkown Pleaseures. The first half of the album flows nicely. Ice Age, Sound of Music and Walked in a line inthemselves are great enough songs to be the marquis tracks of an album inthemselves. I surmise that it was Ian Curtis's suicide that caused these tracks to never get release on a studio album. The other tracks on this half of the album are equally good. Exercise one makes a great opening track with its long building intro and Glass somewhat of a filler song is a great follower to Ice Age.

The second half is a great live album but this is the part that took much mor time to get into. I have quite a few JB bootlegs and they are all ok. In fact while the recording is perfect this is one of the cleanest live recording you can get these days. However, the transition from studo to live tracks, bothered me first. In the several hundred times I have listend to this album I have gotten over it. The versions of Warsaw and New Dawn Fades are aruably better than the studio versions and hearing JD play The Velvet Underground's Sister Ray is really fun. They do a good job with it. Overall this half of the album is Great too... It just might take the modern youth of the world, who are so used to hearing perfect recordings, a little time to get into.

Overall, this is a great album and it is in my top 20 of all time. If you are a JD Fan and you don't own it I implore you to make the purchase now. If you are not yet exposed to JD or just getting familiar with them get this album. It will help you appreciate why they were such a great and inspiring band.

I hope you like it too!

-- Ted Murena
Martin Hannett's Personal Mixes
Average customer rating: Not rated
    Martin Hannett's Personal Mixes
    Joy Division
    Manufacturer: Interstate
    ProductGroup: Music
    Binding: Audio CD

    GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    Hardcore & PunkHardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music | Vinyl Records | American Punk | British Punk | Emo | Garage Punk | Hardcore | Post Hardcore | Proto Punk | Punk | Punk Revival | Punk-Pop | Riot Grrl | Ska Punk | Straight Edge
    Post-PunkPost-Punk | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
    Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
    Similar Items:
    1. Let The Movie Begin
    2. Maximum
    3. Further Transmissions
    4. Joy Division - Under Review
    5. Reformation Post TLC

    ASIN: B000OVL766
    Release Date: 2007-06-19

    Tracks:

    1. Synth Tone
    2. Hannett's Lift Recording 1
    3. Joy Division Keyboard Doodles
    4. Hannett's Lift Recording 2
    5. Joy Division Number False Start 1
    6. Curtis, Hannett, Gretton Interplay, Chit Chat And Cup Smashing
    7. Hannett Speaks
    8. Joy Division Number False Start 2
    9. From Safety To Where
    10. Autosuggestion
    11. Heart And Soul
    12. N4 Europop
    13. 24 Hours
    14. Passover
    15. N4
    16. N4
    17. The Eternal
    18. The Eternal

    Album Description

    Discovered by friends of Martin Hannett recently and with input from one of his relatives,these recordings give a rare insight into his production ideas for Joy Division and his relationship with the band.,the strange things/ sound effects they recorded in the studio together etc etc ,.The studio chit chat and interplay between Hannett and Joy Division members is all here as Martin left his own tape machine running throughout studio sessions. On this album we have rare alternative mixes of Joy Division that were Martin's personal favourites and he had the fore thought to get the band members to give him control of these recordings. A must for all Joy Division fans. Includes alternative mixes of Autosuggestion, Heart and soul, 24 hours, Passover, The Eternal (2 mixes), From Safety to where & Decades (3 mixes).

    Album Details

    Discovered by Friends of Martin Hannett Recently and with Input from One of his Relatives,these Recordings Give a Rare Insight Into his Production Ideas for Joy Division and his Relationship with the Band.,the Strange Things/ Sound Effects They Recorded in the Studio Together Etc Etc ,.the Studio Chit Chat and Interplay Between Hannett, Gretton and Joy Division Members is all Here as Martin Left his Own Tape Machine Running Throughout Studio Sessions. On this Album We have Rare Alternative Mixes of Joy Division that were Martin's Personal Favourites and He Had the Forethought to Get the Band Members to Give Him Control of These Recordings. A Must for all Joy Division Fans. Includes Alternative Mixes of Autosuggestion, Heart and Soul, 24 Hours, Passover, the Eternal (2 Mixes), from Safety to Where and Decades (3 Mixes).
    Heart and Soul
    Average customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    • The Box Set We Should Have Seen for New Order
    • Heart & Soul CD
    • Soul On Ice
    • Grail of Gloom
    • Thse days...
    Heart and Soul
    Joy Division
    Manufacturer: Rhino / Wea
    ProductGroup: Music
    Binding: Audio CD

    GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    Hardcore & PunkHardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music | Vinyl Records | American Punk | British Punk | Emo | Garage Punk | Hardcore | Post Hardcore | Proto Punk | Punk | Punk Revival | Punk-Pop | Riot Grrl | Ska Punk | Straight Edge
    Post-PunkPost-Punk | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
    Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
    Alternative StylesAlternative Styles | Alternative Rock | Box Sets | Stores | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Rock | Box Sets | Stores | Music
    Rhino RecordsRhino Records | Amazon.com Label Stores | Stores | Music
    Similar Items:
    1. Warsaw
    2. Touching from a Distance
    3. Movement
    4. Retro
    5. Still

    ASIN: B00005MKHQ
    Release Date: 2001-08-28

    Tracks:

    1. Digital
    2. Glass
    3. Disorder
    4. Day of the Lords
    5. Candidate
    6. Insight
    7. New Dawn Fades
    8. She's Lost Control
    9. Shadowplay
    10. Wilderness
    11. Interzone
    12. I Remember Nothing
    13. Ice Age
    14. Exercise One
    15. Transmission
    16. Novelty
    17. The Kill
    18. The Only Mistake
    19. Something Must Break
    20. Auto-Suggestion
    21. From Safety to Where...?

    Tracks:

    1. She's Lost Control 12
    2. Sound of Music
    3. Atmosphere
    4. Dead Souls
    5. Komakino
    6. Incubation
    7. Atrocity Exhibition
    8. Isolation
    9. Passover
    10. Colony
    11. Means to an End
    12. Heart and Soul
    13. Twenty Four Hours
    14. The Eternal
    15. Decades
    16. Love Will Tear Us Apart
    17. These Days

    Tracks:

    1. Warsaw
    2. No Love Lost
    3. Leaders of Men
    4. Failures
    5. The Drawback
    6. Interzone
    7. Shadowplay
    8. Exercise One
    9. Insight
    10. Glass
    11. Transmission
    12. Dead Souls
    13. Something Must Break
    14. Ice Age
    15. Walked in Line
    16. These Days
    17. Candidate
    18. The Only Mistake
    19. Chance (Atmosphere)
    20. Love Will Tear Us Apart
    21. Colony
    22. As You Said
    23. Ceremony
    24. In a Lonely Place (Detail)

    Tracks:

    1. Dead Souls [Live]
    2. The Only Mistake [Live]
    3. Insight [Live]
    4. Candidate [Live]
    5. Wilderness [Live]
    6. She's Lost Control [Live]
    7. Disorder [Live]
    8. Interzone [Live]
    9. Atrocity Exhibition [Live]
    10. Novelty [Live]
    11. Auto-Suggestion
    12. Remember Nothing
    13. Colony
    14. These Days
    15. Incubation
    16. The Eternal
    17. Heart and Soul
    18. Isolation
    19. She's Lost Control

    Amazon.com

    Though Joy Division's anxious, angular songs echoed time-honored art-school obsessions from the Doors through Eno, they never stooped to cheap nostalgia or pretentious condescension. Neither bridge nor battering ram, the band's music--haunting and hypnotic, with an emotionally naked core as bleak as it was compelling--has transcended disposable pop culture past and present; leader-vocalist Ian Curtis's 1980 suicide only underscored the notion that Joy Division was a band out of time, figuratively as well as literally. In just over two years, the Manchester, U.K., group constructed a legacy whose influences have surfaced with the surviving members' New Order through macabre, psychically-damaged Curtis/Cobain parallels to the sonic atmospherics of Radiohead. And if their recorded output was limited, it has long been ill served by the record industry's worst Cuisinart instincts. Thus, this artfully designed four-disc, 81-track box should reign as the band's definitive recorded history. Journalist Jon Savage collaborated with band members Bernard Sumner and Peter Hook to assemble Joy Division's legacy into four subtly different chapters. Discs one and two center around the band's albums, Unknown Pleasures and Closer respectively, culling singles, demos, and outtakes. Disc three gathers BBC and Peel sessions and more than a dozen previously unreleased outtakes. The final chapter may be the most artistically revealing: 17 live tracks that represent not only the best of the band's darkly compelling songs, but show their riveting stage presence during a performance peak that spanned but seven months. The accompanying booklet presents an almost Rashomon-like take on the band, from its spare, impressionistic imagery through its multiple essays and, crucially, the lyrics of Ian Curtis, starkly presented as the candid, disquieting poetry that was the essence of Joy Division's murmuring heart and troubled soul. --Jerry McCulley

    Album Description

    1997 release, a four disc set on London packaged in a 6 x 10in gatefold digibook with an 80 page illustrated book. 80 tracks total, including all cuts from the albums 'Unknown Pleasures', 'Closer' & 'Substance', seven of the nine studiorecordings on 'Still', plus Peel session versions of 'Love Will Tear Us Apart', 'Exercise One' & 'Colony', the version of 'As You Said' that appeared as the uncredited track on New Order's 'Video 586' 12 single and last --but certainly not least-- 35 previously unreleased gems comprised of live & rare versions of their absolute finest. Utterly brilliant.

    Album Description

    1997 release, a four disc set on London packaged in a 6 x 10in gatefold digibook with an 80 page illustrated book. 80 tracks total, including all cuts from the albums 'Unknown Pleasures', 'Closer' & 'Substance', seven of the nine studiorecordings on 'Still', plus Peel session versions of 'Love Will Tear Us Apart', 'Exercise One' & 'Colony', the version of 'As You Said' that appeared as the uncredited track on New Order's 'Video 586' 12 single and last --but certainly not least-- 35 previously unreleased gems comprised of live & rare versions of their absolute finest. Utterly brilliant.

    Album Details

    The Most Complete Collection of Joy Division's Studio Recordings Ever, Compiled by the Surviving Band Members and Jon Savage. Both Studio LPs Are Included Along with all Singles, Obscure Tracks and Hard to Find Tracks. The Fourth Disc Includes Previously Unreleased Live Tracks for the Faithful. Not to Mention the Fact that all the Tracks were Digitally Remastered, So They Sound Better Than Ever.

    Customer Reviews:

    5 out of 5 stars The Box Set We Should Have Seen for New Order.......2007-01-22

    This is as close as you can get to the definitive Joy Division collection. The live material is just as good, with all of the concert recordings coming from the soundboard. This is a welcome change from years of scratchy vinyl audience-recorded bootlegs. The best part of this box set has to be the studio demos of two songs never properly released by Joy Division due to Ian's untimely death - 'Ceremony' and 'In A Lonely Place.'

    Although 'Ceremony' was performed at the last live JD venue in Birmingham and found on the Still double LP release, this studio version includes audible lyrics for the first verse. We can't hear Ian in the Still version until the second verse due to soundboard problems. I was disappointed that Peter Hook cuts off 'In A Lonely Place' just as Ian started singing the version that contains, "Hangman looks 'round while he waits; cord stretches tight then in breaks." The official word on this is that during the original demo, the quality of the recording deteriorated after that verse. If that was the case, I'm sure the band would have recorded a second demo after they heard the playback.

    After witnessing this release, I was expecting a similar release for New Order, but unfortunately, the New Order box set excludes many early rarities, like Homage, Haystack, and original 1980 recordings sans Gillian Gilbert.

    Overall, Heart and Soul is a must have for the avid Joy Division aficionado.

    5 out of 5 stars Heart & Soul CD.......2007-01-15

    gave this CD to my daughter-in-law for Christmas as she requested this group. I had never heard of this group before, but they have wonderful music. She loves the CD and I love that you got it here so quickly and the price was great! Thanks!

    5 out of 5 stars Soul On Ice.......2006-09-26

    Joy Division was poised to take the UK post-punk movement to incredible heights until the suicide by singer Ian Curtis in 1980. The band had established itself in two years as a major force in Europe and were set to delve into a U.S. market that was just hearing the final vestiges of punk rock.

    The multi-CD set is a definitive history of the group. The first two disks emphasize the music from Unknown Pleasures and Closer, and offers a mix of singles, outtakes and demos. The third disk has the band reaching a wider audience through the BBC and Peel Sessions, including a nice mix of previously unreleased outtakes.

    The fourth disk is the gem, as the 17 live tracks captures Curtis as artist/performer, singing with passion the lyrics that ultimately ripped his soul apart.

    Curtis was not only the heart and soul of Joy Division, but was thrust into the lead of a burgeoning musical revolution. It was truly a masterpiece while it lasted.

    4 out of 5 stars Grail of Gloom.......2006-01-16

    This is it, this is the most complete Joy Division collection you could ask for. The obsessive collector likely has already assembled all these tracks from various discs, and there really is nothing new for the angst-ridden afficianado, but two things make it worth the price of admission: the convenience of the oeuvre on 4 discs; and the booklet.

    5 out of 5 stars Thse days..........2005-10-10

    These days, there is nothing out there with music as personal and haunting as Joy Division's. My thirst has been quenched. .
    Warsaw
    Average customer rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
    • takes me back...
    • the joy division demos
    • I agree with Daniel - Joy Division at their rawest and best
    • Buy it, Love it, Be it
    • 5 stars for JD fans; this stuff ROCKS!
    Warsaw
    Warsaw (Joy Division)
    Manufacturer: Mpg [Movieplay Gold]
    ProductGroup: Music
    Binding: Audio CD

    GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    PunkPunk | Hardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    British PunkBritish Punk | Hardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    Ska GeneralSka General | Ska | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
    Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
    RockRock | Imports | Stores | Music
    Similar Items:
    1. Still
    2. Unknown Pleasures
    3. Touching from a Distance
    4. Closer
    5. Movement

    ASIN: B0000075Z9
    Release Date: 1995-11-21

    Tracks:

    1. Drawback
    2. Leaders of Men
    3. They Walked in Line
    4. Failures
    5. Novelty
    6. No Love Lost
    7. Transmission
    8. Living in the Ice Age
    9. Interzone
    10. Warsaw
    11. Shadowplay
    12. As You Said
    13. Inside the Line [*]
    14. Gutz [*]
    15. At a Later Date [*]
    16. Kill [*]
    17. You're No Good for Me

    Album Description

    1994 reissue of compilation of early recordings from 1977 byWarsaw, an early moniker for the Mancunian act Joy Division.This pressing features 17 raw, but respectable cuts, including five bonus tracks: 'Inside The Line', 'At A Later Date', 'Gutz', 'The Kill' and 'You're No Good For Me'. Others include 'Failures', 'Leaders Of Men', 'They Walked InLine', 'Novelty', 'No Love Lost', 'Transmission', 'Living InThe Ice Age', 'Interzone', 'Warsaw' and 'Shadowplay'.

    Album Details

    The influential UK post-punk outfit Joy Division used the name Warsaw for a time during the 1970's, prior to encountering a legal wrangle with another group of punks called Warsaw Pakt. This 1999 issue was largely recorded in May of 1978, shortly before they had to adopt their new moniker and it was co-produced & engineered by Brian Auger. The bonus tracks are a five-track demo recorded in 1977.

    Customer Reviews:

    5 out of 5 stars takes me back..........2007-03-31

    This was a great find - it takes me back to those angst filled teenage years. As a major Joy Division fan, I was thrilled to get this CD and get a feel for their evolution as a band. Get New Order - 316 if you want to hear an early New Order still sounding like Joy Division.

    4 out of 5 stars the joy division demos.......2007-02-20

    I have always been a huge fan of all Joy Division derivitives, including New Order, Monaco, and Revenge. This album is the boys from Joy Division before the name change. If you thought JD was raw and stark, try this one on for size. They polished a few of the songs off for later re-release, but this great album captures the pure essence of the band, with Ian is all his glory.

    5 out of 5 stars I agree with Daniel - Joy Division at their rawest and best.......2006-03-15

    Joy Division was a rock band. That comes through on this album. The sound is raw as is the recording but for me it's the best one, the least compromised one the most rebellious one. Great band never to return. One of those inexplicable "clicked".

    5 out of 5 stars Buy it, Love it, Be it.......2005-12-12

    I owned this album for two decades as a bootleg tape that got passed around the Berkeley punk scene in the early eighties, and it never failed to become the favorite music of anyone I turned on to it. Joy Division always seems to sound better (to me) at their rawest, and the lower sound quality adds an edge of doom not found on the sanctioned version (of course this could just be that it reminds me of scratchy records). Either way, if you're a fan of "Closer" or New Order, I'm pretty sure you won't dig this. If you were immediately hypnotized by "Unknown Pleasures" like I was at fifteen, this is essential.

    4 out of 5 stars 5 stars for JD fans; this stuff ROCKS!.......2005-08-17

    This is great for many reasons:

    1) It's a good chance to hear the band as it just started to shed its early punk sound and become much darker-sounding. Its also a chance to hear them without any fancy Martin Hannett production trickery.

    2) It's a remarkable document of just how much Ian's voice changed in a very short time. This is a snarling, snotty sounding, angry young man at the mic - nothing to even hint that in two years he'd be crooning like a despondent Frank Sinatra on songs like "Love Will Tear Us Apart" and "Heart And Soul". Listen to "Walked in Line" on this album and compare it to the version from "Still." Its hard to believe they were only done a year apart.

    3) It's got a couple of what i feel are the best versions of Joy Division songs: "Shadowplay," "No Love Lost," "Leaders of Men," and "Novelty" all sound better here, even in their somewhat rough recordings, than any other version I know of.

    4) Only 3 of the 11 songs here are included on the box set.

    5) For sheer comic value, you have to love the last five songs - these are the earliest, rawest recordings of Joy Division. Sometimes I just crack up listening to these incredibly primitive cuts - "You're No Good For Me" could have been done by any number of booze-soaked louts. But even as early as July '77 Ian's lyrics were already chilling: "Human beings are dangerous and they call me in the dark" (At A Later Date), for example. Plus you get the immortal "Warsaww!!!" howl at the beginning of "Gutz."

    This is a very good "punk" album and a very interesting Joy Division album. Highly recommended.
    The Complete BBC Recordings
    Average customer rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
    • A lot of great stuff "Heart and Soul" left out
    • Transmission: Intensity Times Two
    • Joy Division through a different lens.
    • Great sample of important band
    • Peel Be Big Pimpin'
    The Complete BBC Recordings
    Joy Division
    Manufacturer: Varese Sarabande
    ProductGroup: Music
    Binding: Audio CD

    GeneralGeneral | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    Hardcore & PunkHardcore & Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music | Vinyl Records | American Punk | British Punk | Emo | Garage Punk | Hardcore | Post Hardcore | Proto Punk | Punk | Punk Revival | Punk-Pop | Riot Grrl | Ska Punk | Straight Edge
    GeneralGeneral | Live Albums | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    Post-PunkPost-Punk | New Wave & Post-Punk | Alternative Rock | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Rock | Styles | Music
    GeneralGeneral | Live Albums | Rock | Styles | Music
    Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
    Similar Items:
    1. Warsaw
    2. Still
    3. Touching from a Distance
    4. Preston 28 February 1980
    5. Heart and Soul

    ASIN: B00004ZEJ9
    Release Date: 2000-10-24

    Tracks:

    1. Exercise One
    2. Insight
    3. She's Lost Control
    4. Transmission
    5. Love Will Tear Us Apart
    6. 24 Hours
    7. Colony
    8. Sound Of Music
    9. Transmission
    10. She's Lost Control
    11. Ian Curtis & Stephen Morris Interviewed By Richard Skinner

    Amazon.com

    The ever-expanding log of BBC vault recordings is a decidedly mixed lot, with plenty of rubbish surfacing along with more than a few gems. This 10-song collection from the short-lived but vastly influential foursome Joy Division definitely belongs in the latter camp. Made up of radio performances cut in January, September, and November of 1979, The Complete BBC Recordings captures the post-punk outfit two years after they came together following a Sex Pistols appearance in their Manchester, England, base and a matter of months before frontman Ian Curtis took his life. Signaling a tidal shift in the punk mindset, Curtis's inner torment was expressed by melancholy rather than rage. His instrumental cohorts--the pre-New Order trio of Bernard Sumner, Peter Hook, and Stephen Morris--created a sound that was as terse yet expressive as a rude remark. These John Peel and Radio One performances depict a band on a grim mission--to give their sense of paralyzing futility an undeniable momentum. Riveting from start to finish, The Complete BBC Recordings is a must-own for fans of the band and anyone interested in hearing where the '70s ended and the '80s began for a vital segment of British rock. --Steven Stolder

    Customer Reviews:

    5 out of 5 stars A lot of great stuff "Heart and Soul" left out.......2005-08-08

    "Heart and Soul" is an amazing and comprehensive overview of Joy Division's brief but crucial recorded legacy. HOWEVER, it omits the following BBC Sessions: "Insight," "Transmission," (both versions), "She's Lost Control" (both versions), "The Sound Of Music" and "Twenty Four Hours." This means almost all of this CD is NOT on Heart and Soul. Which means you should buy it. Now here's my review:

    True there were occasional overdubs of a guitar here or vocal there, but Peel Sessions, at least from the punk era, were a great chance to get a "live" recording, but with studio conditions more conducive to solid band performances. Joy Division, never a particularly proficient bunch of musicians, benefitted tremendously from the setting the John Peel Show offered.

    Ian's voice on both these sessions was thankfully in good shape. He sounds strong and, relatively speaking, his pitch is solid. His yell at the end of "Transmission" still gives me chills, 15 years after I discovered the 12" vinyl of Session 1. Stephen, Bernie and Hooky all turn in their most consistent, assured performances of the Joy Division era.

    Personally, I consider the versions of "Exercise One," "Insight" and "Sound Of Music" to be the definitive versions of these songs. But all eight of the original two Peel Sessions are nothing short of stellar. Of particular interest are the different lyrics in verse 2 of "Colony" and the overall feel of "Love Will Tear Us Apart" without the overdubbed high-hat part on the studio version.

    The extra versions of "Transmission" and "She's Lost Control" come from a different British radio show, "Something Else" and were recorded on September 15, 1979. Both are good, but a tad inferior in sound quality. "She's Lost Control" is absolutely manic - a little too fast for my taste.

    More than anything, it was the Peel Sessions that got me into Joy Division. If you are not a big fan of the (over)production style of Martin Hannett, then you should love this. In any case, this is top quality live-in-the-studio material from a great, unique band.

    5 out of 5 stars Transmission: Intensity Times Two.......2005-04-28

    As we approach the 25th anniversary of the death of Ian Curtis, the loss magnifies, and the impact made by Joy Division becomes ever more apparent. Moby. Nine Inch Nails. Interpol. The list of artists influenced by Joy Division are too many to mention.

    Begin with Unknown Pleasures or the Substance Collection, but pick up the BBC sessions not only for better versions of Transmission and Exercise One -- untouched by producer Martin Hannett (just as C. Roark "tri-zeta" pointed out in the first review posted here [though I will point out the Pink Floyd influence is impossible, as Joy Division's Peel session was from January 1979 and Pink Floyd's The Wall was not released until November that year]) -- but also for what used to be rare recordings of Transmission and She's Lost Control (tracks 9 and 10 here) from Something Else (recorded for Radio One in September 1979).

    When all's said and done, it's the two versions of Transmission that are worth the price of this BBC Sessions disc. The first, from the John Peel show, is a different and superior arrangement than what you'll hear on Substance. The latter, though a little raspy, is just plain intense. And that intensity is what Joy Division is all about.

    4 out of 5 stars Joy Division through a different lens........2004-11-04

    This is Joy Division away from the influences of Martin Hannett, who produced both their studio albums and is largely credited with helping craft their sound. I was rather suprised by the consistency of these tracks. There are only 10, and both Transmission and SLC get worked over twice. They are pretty tight, demonstrating that Joy Division's songs were about substance and not style- they sounded just as great when transmuted to a different settting. The sound is more full-bodied, not as cold and skeletal as the Hannett productions. Again, I was happily surprised.

    Exercise One (great song, even despite that it subtley plagiarizes a Pink Floyd riff from "The Wall") is short and crisp. Insight is denser- never liked that track so much. The first SLC is very digitized, sounds somewhere between the studio take and the 12"... they definitely played with it. Transmission (1) is one of the more consistent sounding (studio) takes I've heard (better done live on many bootlegs) of it. LWTUA is easily as good as the studio takes released for Factory. 24 Hours seems faster and more confident heret than on Closer. Ian's voice sounds better too- I like the drum-sound, well done. Colony kinda bugs me- not as sludgy as it should sound, I think. I like the Closer version better. Still, Ian's voice is good on the track. Sound of Music is much denser and deeper here than on the single. Transmission (2) is very quick-paced and pretty thin. It's not as urgent or tense as the first take. Finally, the second version of SLC is very fast and urgent and raw as hell- sounds like a schizo demo! It's uniquely badass, and stands up alongside both the studio and 12" versions! Love it- the guitar, when it comes in, is like a fistfull of bees and saw blades.

    All in all, pretty solid. The interview is kind of a letdown- standard interview fare. Very short- about 3 minutes or something. The fact that's there's so few tracks make this prety much for the hardcore fanatics, zealots and true believers, only. The average JD fan probably won't like this as much as the elect- but then, oh well...

    5 out of 5 stars Great sample of important band.......2004-09-18

    For new and old fans of Joy Division, this disc is a gem, period. The sound quality of most of the tracks is fantastic--some of the versions here sound better than the studio ones, especially Transmission, which has a crisper and more energetic feel to it than its studio counterpart.

    I've rarely been disappointed with collected BBC and Peel Sessions discs. John Peel's show allowed bands to re-record their songs live in a studio environment for later broadcast. This gives the songs a live energy combined with the control of the studio for excellent sound.

    Only the last two songs really differ in quality, sounding a bit more raw and bootleg-ish, but the disc as a whole does not disappoint. She's Lost Control makes good use of powerful electronics, Insight has a cold, frantic feel. I think the version of Love Will Tears Us Apart is one of the best available anywhere--the energy, speed, and sound are fantastic. I think it blows away the studio version.

    The interview isn't bad, about ten minutes long, discussing the Manchester vs London scene, the record label business, etc. All in all, this is a no-brainer for any Joy Division fan. It's also an excellent starter for new fans as well. One of the best CDs I own.

    3 out of 5 stars Peel Be Big Pimpin'.......2004-07-16

    I've listened to quite a few live albums from bands performing for John Peel's radio show. And Peel can really get great stuff from the artists recording. Here we have Joy Division's 1979 live tracks and some of them are great, they even include two you can't get on any of their albums, "Exercise One" and "Sound Of Music". The former is a great song and really shines on the album, the latter, however, is a bit weak in comparison with the rest of the material and feels more like a decent b-side more than anything. What is remarkable is how you can't hardly tell that this is a live recording, the production is really just that good. One of the versions of "She's Lost Control" on the album is probably better than the studio versions, which were already excellent on their own. But who really needs two live versions of She's Los Control, definately not the average music listener nor me, that's why I would only pick this up to see what they sound like while not in the studio. There are plenty of gems on here like "Insight" and "Twenty-Four Hours" but it has stuff like "Sound Of Music" and the multiple versions of "She's Lost Control" which you don't really need. Not to mention the interview which doesn't really have anything that extraordinary to say and is only for the hardcore fan. The music is great, as is all Joy Division, but there are other better collections that have most of these songs on them, so it just feels unneeeded.

    Music:

    1. Don't Miss The Boat
    2. Dreamtime Lullabies
    3. Early Childhood Songs
    4. El Lobo: Songs & Games of Latin America
    5. Elmo Saves Christmas
    6. Elmopalooza!
    7. Fable [Import]
    8. Favorite Nursery Rhymes
    9. For Kids by Kids: Poems and Songs
    10. Four Seasons: Springsongs

    Music

    Music